Dunfanaghy, County Donegal — September 2017
The trouble with loving Rory McDaid was that he could make an argument feel like the best evening of your life, right up until it wasn’t.
At twenty-three, he had the crooked half-smile of a man who knew exactly what it did to Niamh, and the practical habits of somebody’s elderly grandfather. He kept an emergency torch in the glove box, knew the tide tables by heart and believed a cup of tea could improve any situation that did not involve a compound fracture. When Niamh Karras burned the toast, he scraped it with a knife and ate it. When she was frightened of something, he never told her not to be frightened. He asked what part of it she could control, and sat with her for the rest.
It was the reason she had loved him for four years.
It was also the reason leaving was going to tear her in half.
Rory stood at the cooker with a tea towel thrown over one shoulder, reading something on his phone and turning two steaks in a pan. He had been on his feet since half six, repairing a trawler’s gearbox for a man who insisted the fault had appeared ‘all of a sudden’, despite there being approximately a litre of water where oil ought to have been. He’d come home, showered, shaved the dark stubble off his cheeks and started dinner because Niamh had rung at lunchtime and sounded tired.
He looked up when she came in.
‘Hello, trouble.’
He said it with the little half-smile that used to be private property, belonging only to her. She had once made the mistake of telling him it made her knees go weak. He’d been an insufferable bastard about it ever since.
Then he saw the suitcase.
One wheel clicked with every revolution as she pulled it across the tiles.
He glanced at it. ‘What’s the story there? Are we being evicted?’
‘No.’
‘Because if we are, I’d have liked some notice. There’s a washing on.’
She set the suitcase upright.
It immediately leaned to one side.
He eyed it with professional disapproval. ‘That wheel’s finished. What did you do, drag it behind a tractor?’
‘Rory.’
The way she said his name made him put down the tongs.
He switched off the ring without taking his eyes from her. The steak hissed once more in the cooling pan. That, at least, could wait.
‘Who’s hurt?’ he asked.
‘Nobody.’
‘Your mam?’
‘She’s fine.’
‘Eleni?’
At that, something flickered across Niamh’s face.
Rory came around the counter. ‘What happened?’
‘Granny’s been poorly. Worse than she let on.’
‘Ah, Niamh. Why didn’t you tell me?’
‘Because I didn’t know how bad it was. And there’s the hotel.’
‘What hotel?’
‘In Greece.’
He blinked. ‘Are you telling me your grandmother’s house with the blue shutters is a hotel?’
‘It’s both. I’ve explained this before.’
‘You’ve shown me photographs of a lovely building and a woman holding an octopus like it owed her money. That was the extent of the explanation.’
Niamh laughed, but it was a thin, damaged sound.
He reached for her hand. She let him take it. It was cold.
‘Come here,’ he said.
She went into his arms and held on so tightly he felt it in his spine. He lowered his mouth to her hair. She smelled of rain and the perfume she wore even when she was only going out for bread.
‘Whatever it is, we’ll sort it,’ he murmured.
She was quiet for a moment. ‘I’ve accepted a job there.’
He drew back enough to see her face.
‘Where?’
‘At the hotel. Granny needs somebody she trusts to help put it right. I’d be handling the bookings and the renovation. There’s a lot I could do.’
‘That sounds good.’ He meant it. Her degree had been hard won, fitted around shifts and the thousand small jobs she took on for other people. ‘When?’
‘Sunday.’
He looked towards the kitchen clock. ‘This Sunday?’
‘Yes.’
‘That’s in three days.’
‘I know.’
‘For how long?’
She looked away.
A gust rattled the loose pane over the sink. The kitchen seemed to wait with him.
‘At least a year,’ she said.
He let go of her hand.
The movement was small. Niamh watched the gap between their hands open on the kitchen tiles.
‘A year.’
‘Maybe it won’t be. I need to see what’s involved.’
‘You’ve accepted a year-long job, booked your journey and brought the suitcase home before telling me.’
‘I tried to tell you.’
‘When?’
‘Loads of times.’
‘You told me we needed to buy washing-up liquid.’
‘Because you were going to work and your father was waiting in the van, and it never seemed like the right time.’
He nodded, once, the way he did when an engine was giving him bad news. Niamh knew he was thinking carefully. He wasn’t a man who shouted for the pleasure of it.
‘You should go to your grandmother,’ he said at last. ‘I wouldn’t ever tell you different.’
Niamh’s shoulders eased.
‘But you should have trusted me enough to tell me before the decision was made.’
The relief vanished. She looked down.
‘I know.’
He glanced at the suitcase. ‘And what happens to us?’
‘Come with me.’
It was the answer she had rehearsed for weeks, in the bathroom, in the car, lying beside him while he slept. Spoken aloud, it sounded terribly small.
Rory watched her.
‘Niamh.’
‘Come for a while. Six months. Even three. You can fix anything with an engine. There’ll be work.’
‘I have work.’
‘I know.’
‘Here. With my father.’
‘I know that too.’
‘Then you know I can’t just leave him short.’
‘He can employ somebody.’
‘That’s not the point.’
‘No,’ she said quietly. ‘I suppose it isn’t.’
He looked at her then, properly. ‘What does that mean?’
‘It means you’ve never wanted to live anywhere except within shouting distance of this kitchen.’
‘And what’s wrong with this kitchen? You’ve decorated the whole bloody thing.’
‘There’s nothing wrong with it. There’s nothing wrong with Donegal. I love Donegal.’
‘But not enough.’
‘Don’t.’
He stopped. That was a cruelty he hadn’t intended, and they both knew it.
Niamh picked at the hem of her sleeve. ‘I want to find out what I can do when I’m somewhere new. I want to help Granny. I want you to come and see it with me, not because you’ve been dragged there but because I’m asking you to share something that matters to me.’
Rory rubbed his jaw. ‘I’ll look into it.’
‘Will you?’
‘If I say I will, I will.’
She nodded. He had never lied to her about a practical thing in his life. If he said he would look, he would look.
But she wanted him to want to go.
And he wanted her to want to stay.
They ate the steaks lukewarm, sitting opposite each other at the table they had painted together. For the first time in four years, neither reached across it.
⁂
The next day, Rory’s father caught him studying a road map that had not seen daylight since the family holiday to Sligo in 2008.
Jim McDaid leaned against the workshop door. ‘Where are we off to?’
‘Nowhere.’
‘Aye, I recognised the determined expression of a man planning a journey to nowhere.’
Rory folded the map. ‘Niamh’s going to Greece.’
Jim didn’t answer immediately. He took his time with most things, including the small brass fittings he polished for customers who would never notice.
‘How is her grandmother?’ he asked.
‘Not great. Niamh’s going to help run the hotel.’
‘Good girl.’
‘She wants me with her.’
‘And do you want to go?’
‘No.’
Jim nodded. ‘That sounded convincing.’
‘It’s not a matter of wanting. There’s the workshop.’
‘I own the workshop.’
‘I work here.’
‘And I’m grateful. Particularly on the days you don’t tell me how I ought to run it.’
Rory leaned against the bench. ‘I can’t leave you on your own.’
‘Your mother and I have survived your absence before. There were at least three years when you refused to come home for dinner unless there was chicken.’
‘You told me it was chicken and served haddock.’
‘Character building.’
Rory almost smiled.
Jim came closer. His hands were stained around the nails, the skin permanently marked by work, and Rory had loved them since childhood: hands that could rebuild a crankshaft and peel an orange in one unbroken spiral.
‘Son,’ Jim said, ‘I don’t need you to stay here for me.’
‘You’re making this sound very easy.’
‘It isn’t. You’ll miss home. You might hate Greece. You might go for three weeks and come back saying I was a fool to encourage it. But I won’t have you blaming me, ten years from now, for something you never tried.’
Rory stared at the floor.
‘You’re mad about that girl,’ Jim added.
‘Aye.’
‘Then talk to her about what the two of you want. Not what you think ought to happen.’
‘Are you offering advice or trying to get rid of me?’
‘Both. Your mother says you’re using all the hot water.’
That earned a laugh.
Jim slapped his shoulder and went back to the engine. Rory unfolded the map again.
Greece looked an awfully long way from home.
⁂
Bríd found him that evening sitting on the back step, staring towards the sea with his phone in his hand.
‘Your father says you’re going travelling.’
Rory looked up. ‘Does he, now?’
‘He’s very proud. I expect he’ll put it in the parish newsletter.’
‘I haven’t agreed to anything.’
‘That explains why you’ve spent the afternoon looking at ferries.’
She sat beside him, a little red-haired woman in a cardigan she’d mended twice rather than replace. She carried two slices of apple tart and handed him the larger one. She had always done that. When he was five, he thought it was because he was growing. At twenty-three, he knew it was because she loved him.
‘You know what I was going to do?’ he asked.
‘Get another ear pierced? I’d advise against it. The first was bad enough.’
‘Ask Niamh to marry me.’
Bríd lowered her fork.
He regretted saying it. ‘Not right away.’
‘Rory Joseph.’
‘Next summer, maybe. When we’ve a bit more put away.’
‘Have you told her this?’
He looked at the sea.
‘Ah, sweet Jesus,’ his mother said.
‘What?’
‘You’ve planned a proposal without letting the poor girl know there’s a wedding under consideration.’
‘I’d have told her when I proposed. That’s usually how it works.’
‘Have you told her you want a marriage? A family? A house of your own?’
‘We’ve talked about having kids.’
‘Some day.’
‘Aye.’
Bríd shook her head, exasperated and affectionate. ‘Some day is a lovely place to live when you’re not the one waiting for a decision.’
Rory bit into the tart. He was old enough to know she was right and young enough to resent it.
‘She wants me to go somewhere I don’t belong.’
‘Have you been?’
‘No.’
‘Then how would you know?’
He watched two gulls quarrel over a crust in the yard. They sounded like politicians being asked a direct question.
Bríd moved her hand across the step and covered his.
‘You belong to people, love. Places are important, but they aren’t the only thing that makes a home.’
He swallowed the last of the tart without tasting it.
‘And before you say you’ll miss us,’ she continued, ‘you should know your father and I intend to have an extremely pleasant time once you stop appearing uninvited at dinner.’
‘I pay for half the groceries.’
‘And eat three-quarters.’
He smiled despite himself.
She leaned into his shoulder. Neither spoke for a while. A boat moved far out on the Atlantic, its lights small and unwavering against the darkening water.
‘Tell her what you want,’ Bríd said at last. ‘And listen when she tells you what she wants. The second bit is the important one.’
⁂
They went to Marble Hill before Niamh left.
Rory brought two takeaway coffees and a packet of biscuits that had been crushed under the passenger seat. Niamh took one look at the biscuit dust and informed him his romantic instincts had the precision of a reversing cement lorry.
‘I bought the expensive coffee,’ he said.
‘And sat on the biscuits.’
‘A balanced gesture.’
The beach was nearly empty. Wind dragged their words away, and the waves ran over the sand with the low, tireless roar he had heard every day of his life.
She took her shoes off. He carried them without being asked.
‘You looked at the ferries,’ she said.
‘Aye.’
‘And?’
‘Dublin to Holyhead. Drive through Britain, across France. There are a few ways after that. Some worse than others. You could lose a fortnight trying to follow the scenic route.’
‘You could fly.’
‘I could also place myself inside a tumble dryer and hope for the best.’
‘You’ve flown before.’
‘Once. I didn’t enjoy the bit where the ground disappeared.’
Niamh laughed, but the laugh ebbed too soon.
‘You’d come for Christmas?’
‘I’ve talked to Dad. I could come for a month. See how the place is. See if there’s work.’
She looked at him. ‘And after?’
‘I can’t promise the rest before I’ve tried the first bit.’
‘No.’ She nodded. ‘You can’t.’
He stopped walking. ‘That isn’t a refusal. It’s me trying to do this properly.’
‘I know.’
‘Then why do you look like I’ve told you the dog’s dead?’
‘Because I’ve spent four years fitting myself around a future you won’t describe out loud.’
He stared at her.
‘I love our life,’ she said. ‘I do. But you’ve already chosen every part of it, Rory. Donegal. The workshop. This house. I want to know there’s room for something I choose.’
He looked towards the water. There was no clever way through that sentence.
‘I was going to ask you to marry me,’ he said.
Niamh stopped breathing for a moment.
He went on before he could lose the nerve. ‘Not here. Not with smashed biscuits and seaweed under our feet. I was saving. Next summer, I thought. I knew you wanted a proper proposal.’
‘Rory.’
‘Aye.’
She looked at him so long he began to wish the tide would come in and finish him off.
‘Why didn’t you tell me?’
‘I thought you knew where we were going.’
‘I thought so too,’ she whispered.
He drew her close and kissed her. He knew how to kiss her without thinking; knew the pause she liked, the way she tipped her chin up and then smiled against his mouth as if the whole thing had been her idea. She held his face in both hands. Her fingers were cold. He pulled her nearer until the wind could hardly get between them.
He loved her. That was not in doubt.
But love, he discovered that evening, did not automatically tell two people what to do with the distance between their dreams.
‘Come with me,’ she whispered.
He rested his forehead against hers.
‘I’ll try,’ he said.
It was the truest promise he could give. It was not the promise she wanted.
⁂
On Sunday he drove her to Letterkenny for the airport coach. He checked the oil, inspected the tyres, took her suitcase out and repaired the loose wheel with a cable tie while Niamh stood beside him crying and laughing in equal measure.
‘You carry cable ties in your car?’ she asked.
‘Doesn’t everyone?’
‘I’m leaving a deeply peculiar man.’
‘And yet a useful one.’
When the coach arrived, he gave her an envelope with three hundred euro inside. She protested. He reminded her he was extraordinarily difficult to argue with when he was right, and she said he had never experienced that sensation in his life.
He could have held her for an hour. They had three minutes.
‘Ring when you land,’ he said.
‘You’ll answer?’
‘Every time.’
She kissed him. The driver called for her to board. Rory carried the suitcase the last few steps because there were still things he could do for her, and he needed to do every single one.
As the coach pulled away, she pressed her fingers to the glass. He lifted his hand. He waited until it had vanished, then climbed into his car and sat looking at the empty passenger seat.
He did not cry at first.
That came when he reached for the heating controls and realised he had already turned them towards her side, the way he always did because she was permanently cold.
He pulled into a lay-by, put his head against the steering wheel, and let himself miss her.
⁂
For three weeks they managed.
They rang each other at ridiculous hours and talked about little things. The hotel’s ancient lift. The trawler Rory was repairing. Eleni’s insistence that everybody was too thin. A receptionist who had misplaced three bookings and apparently blamed the Greek economy.
They flirted. They argued about football. On a wet night in October, Rory read Niamh an entire safety notice from a new drill because she said she missed the sound of his voice and he refused to become sentimental about it. She laughed until he had to stop reading.
Then life, with its ordinary capacity for cruelty, became busy.
He missed two calls because an engine seized while a boat was out. She missed three because the hotel was understaffed. Her grandmother had another spell of dizziness. A booking system failed. Rory’s father hurt his shoulder and needed help at the workshop. By the time they spoke they were both tired, and tired people are sometimes dishonest without saying anything untrue.
‘I love it here,’ Niamh said one night.
He stared at the burn mark on the kitchen table, left by a pan she’d set down the previous Christmas.
‘Good.’
‘I might want to stay longer than a year.’
‘Right.’
‘Please don’t make that sound like an accusation.’
He closed his eyes. ‘I’m trying not to.’
‘You don’t want the same life I want.’
‘I want you.’
‘But only in Donegal.’
‘That’s not fair.’
‘Maybe not. But I can’t pretend we’re making a plan when we’re waiting for the other person to change their mind.’
He spent a long time trying to find a sentence that would save them. A sentence clever enough, honest enough, brave enough.
He found none.
‘Are you ending this?’ he asked.
She cried before she answered.
‘I don’t want us to become people who hate each other.’
‘We aren’t those people.’
‘Not yet.’
The line crackled. He listened to her breathing from a country he had never seen.
‘Right,’ he said, because it was the only word left to him.
She told him she loved him. He believed her, which somehow hurt more.
After the call, he typed three messages and deleted them all. The last one said, I was going to marry you.
He never sent it.
⁂
Six weeks after that, Niamh sat in a clinic outside Parga and watched a doctor turn the ultrasound monitor towards her.
She had suspected she was pregnant when coffee began to smell like petrol. Three tests had confirmed it. Her grandmother had made toast, hugged her, and said that if Rory was as good a man as Niamh had always claimed, he deserved to know.
Niamh agreed.
Agreeing and finding the courage to do it were proving to be different things.
The doctor moved the probe. A pale shape appeared on the screen, small and imperfectly formed.
‘There,’ she said. ‘That is the first heartbeat.’
Niamh reached blindly for Eleni’s hand.
‘The first?’
The doctor moved the probe again.
‘And there is the second.’
Eleni made a noise halfway between a laugh and a prayer.
Niamh stared. ‘I’m sorry. The second what?’
‘Heartbeat. Two babies.’
Niamh’s mouth opened. Closed. Opened again.
‘Are you sure?’
The doctor smiled. ‘Very.’
‘Because I’m from a family where people exaggerate. My aunt once said she’d broken her leg when she’d stubbed her toe.’
The doctor pointed to the screen again. ‘Two.’
Eleni began crying. Niamh laughed in disbelief. She imagined two little people filling Rory’s quiet house with noise, saw him crouching to help with a bicycle, sitting on the floor to tie a shoe, pretending not to enjoy himself while giving away the last biscuit.
The thought was so clear and so painful that she had to look away.
‘He needs to know,’ Eleni said gently when they were outside.
‘I know.’
‘Not when it is convenient. Not when you have made yourself brave enough. Soon.’
Niamh pressed her hand against the place where two lives had quietly begun. ‘I know, Granny.’
She said it as if sincerity could be made into a deadline.
She took out her phone and found Rory’s name. It was still saved with a heart beside it.
She called. The signal broke before she could speak. She tried again. The phone rang, then failed.
She could have sent a message. She knew that. She could have written the words plainly and accepted whatever came back.
Instead she stared at his name, with two grainy ultrasound pictures in her other hand, and told herself she would call from the hotel that evening.
The phone went dark before she pressed call.