Chapter Two
The first shoe was in the fridge.
Darragh Keane found it between a carton of milk and a bowl of strawberries, its white sole pressed against the cling film as if it had been put there to chill. He looked at it for a long moment. Then he shut the door.
‘Eabha.’
From upstairs came the heavy silence of a twelve-year-old deciding whether she could reasonably claim not to exist.
‘Before you say anything,’ she called, ‘I didn't do it.’
‘That's a powerful defence, considering I haven't said what “it” is.’
‘Oisín did it.’
‘Even stronger. You should study law.’
He took the shoe out again. The laces were knotted together in a manner that suggested either a deliberate act of sabotage or a very small person's belief in engineering. His son appeared at the kitchen door wearing one sock and a goalkeeper's jersey over his school shirt.
‘Why is my shoe cold?’ Oisín asked.
‘An excellent question. We should probably start with why your shoe was refrigerated.’
Oisín considered this. ‘Eabha said my feet smell like a dead fox.’
‘That's not an explanation.’
‘She said cold kills germs.’
‘That's closer to an explanation. Still not a good one.’
The boy accepted the shoe and sat on the floor to put it on, apparently content that the matter had reached its natural conclusion. Darragh checked the time. Eight seventeen. His meeting with Rían Kelleher was at nine, and Kelleher was a man who treated punctuality as a virtue in other people and a suggestion in himself.
The kitchen smelled of burnt toast, wet coats and the coffee Darragh had made twenty minutes earlier and not yet touched. On the counter sat two lunchboxes, a permission slip, and a note from Sinéad reminding him that Oisín's inhaler needed to go back in the schoolbag. Sinéad had sent the reminder at six forty-two, along with a photograph of a replacement lunchbox clasp and the words YOU OWE ME ONE. Their marriage had not survived. Their ability to run a household across two addresses had, through a combination of spreadsheets and stubbornness, become almost professional.
He put the inhaler into the front pocket and answered her message: INHALER DONE. I OWE YOU SEVERAL HUNDRED. She sent back a thumbs-up and then, a second later, DON'T FORGET EABHA'S MEETING THURSDAY.
He had not forgotten. He had written it on the calendar, his phone, and the back of his hand before yesterday's shower. That did not mean Sinéad was wrong to remind him.
Eabha came down with her school jumper inside out, carrying a hairbrush and two mismatched hair ties. She stopped when she saw the shoe in Oisín's hand.
‘Traitor,’ she said to her brother.
‘Scientist,’ Darragh corrected. ‘Apparently we're conducting cold-storage trials now.’
‘His shoes are disgusting.’
‘They'll be less disgusting when they're on his feet. Turn around.’
She gave him the brush. He stood behind her and began working through the tangles with the care of a man defusing something expensive. He had learned to plait her hair when she was four, after she informed him that the ponytails he made looked like ‘a frightened onion’. These days she could do it herself. Some mornings she still handed him the brush.
‘Are you coming Thursday?’ she asked.
‘Yes.’
‘Mum says you might have work.’
‘Mum said I might have work. She didn't say I wouldn't come.’
‘That's what people say when they don't want to promise.’
He paused with a section of hair between his fingers. Eabha watched him in the dark reflection of the kitchen window. She had inherited Sinéad's eyes and neither parent's tolerance for nonsense.
‘I'll be there,’ he said.
‘All of it?’
‘All of it.’
‘Not the first ten minutes and then an emergency?’
‘Not the first ten minutes.’
She nodded, satisfied enough to let him finish. He fastened the plait with a green tie and slipped the spare purple one into his coat pocket. She noticed, of course. She noticed everything.
‘You keep collecting them.’
‘I'm building a retirement fund.’
‘Hair ties aren't currency.’
‘Neither was cryptocurrency once. Look how that turned out.’
She rolled her eyes. But she smiled.
At eight thirty-one he got both children into the car. Oisín had found the second shoe under the passenger seat, which raised further questions Darragh did not have the strength to pursue. At the school gate, his son remembered the football form and his daughter remembered the permission slip. Darragh produced both from his coat, along with a crushed cereal bar and a biro without a lid. He watched them cross the yard: Oisín running, Eabha walking as if speed were an embarrassing concession to the world.
His phone rang before they reached the door.
Kelleher.
Darragh let it ring. He waited until Oisín turned, waved both arms and disappeared into the building. Only then did he answer.
‘Morning, Rían.’
‘Where are you?’
‘At a school.’
‘Why?’
‘I'm trying to improve my education.’
‘This isn't funny.’
‘Then you've called the wrong man.’
There was a breath on the line, an exhalation too deliberate to be natural. ‘You were supposed to be in the office by now.’
‘We said nine.’
‘It's important.’
‘It'll still be important in twenty minutes.’
‘The accountant has been making enquiries.’
Darragh watched the school doors close. Beyond them, a teacher was lifting a dropped coat from the wet concrete. A small, ordinary kindness. He thought of the message Maeve Sloane had sent the night before: Public place. No conditions. Bring the truth if you've any left.
‘Accountants tend to do that,’ he said.
‘Don't be clever.’
‘You'll have to be more specific.’
‘She's got a ledger.’
The traffic behind him began to move. He stayed where he was for one more second, his thumb resting on the seam of the steering wheel.
‘Which ledger?’
‘You know which.’
‘If I knew, I wouldn't have asked.’
Kelleher said nothing. Darragh could almost hear him choosing what could safely be said over a telephone. It was one of the reasons Bellharbour paid him: not because he knew how to threaten people, though he had done enough of that to regret the distinction, but because he could hear the unsaid portion of a conversation and give it a shape.
‘Come in,’ Kelleher said. ‘Now.’
‘I'll be there when I'm there.’
He ended the call and drove towards the city. At the first set of lights he caught sight of himself in the rear-view mirror: white shirt, dark coat, face still carrying the easy expression he'd used at the school gate. He looked like a man whose morning had been inconvenienced by missing footwear. He was a man whose name had appeared in a file that should never have been made incomplete.
Both things were true. That was the difficulty.
***
Bellharbour's offices occupied three floors of a building with a view of the river and a reception desk so polished it reflected the underside of visitors' chins. Darragh had once made the mistake of telling Kelleher that the place looked like a bank trying to disguise itself as a hotel. Kelleher had stopped speaking to him for a week. It remained one of Darragh's happier professional memories.
The receptionist offered coffee. He declined. He was already late and had no interest in giving Kelleher the satisfaction of seeing him rush.
In the meeting room, Rían Kelleher stood beside a window holding a thin folder. He wore a tie the colour of a fresh bruise.
‘Twenty-six minutes,’ Kelleher said.
‘Did you time me?’
‘I had other things to do.’
‘Then I'm glad you found a hobby.’
Kelleher placed the folder on the table. He did not sit. Darragh took the chair opposite him and looked at the folder without opening it.
‘Tell me what you want.’
‘Maeve Sloane. Independent forensic accountant. She has been asking questions about Carrig Court.’
‘I know who she is.’
‘Then you know she's trouble.’
‘Most people asking questions are trouble to someone. Doesn't make the questions wrong.’
Kelleher's mouth tightened. ‘I didn't bring you here for a lecture.’
‘Good. I charge more for those.’
‘She has access to settlement material.’
‘Material that should be retained.’
‘Material that has been misinterpreted.’
Darragh waited. The silence lengthened. He had learned years ago that powerful men hated a pause because they assumed it meant someone else had taken control of the room.
Kelleher opened the folder himself. There were three photocopied pages, each bearing the Bellharbour mark. Darragh recognised the numbering before he recognised the text. A schedule of payments. A legal summary. A reconciliation table. He looked at the last page for a little too long.
‘Where's the annex?’ he asked.
‘What annex?’
Darragh looked up. ‘We can do this for an hour, Rían, or we can save ourselves the performance.’
‘There is no annex in that file.’
‘There was.’
‘You've been away from this matter for years.’
‘That doesn't change what was in it.’
Kelleher sat down at last. ‘The company complied with the agreement reached at the time.’
‘That's a sentence. It's not an answer.’
‘You helped us reach that agreement.’
There it was: the first small movement of the blade. Darragh kept his hands flat on the table. Ten years ago, he had carried an envelope between people who wore good suits and used careful words. He had believed, or persuaded himself to believe, that the engineering report inside would force repairs. When the report failed to appear in the final settlement bundle, he had asked one question, accepted an answer that should not have satisfied him, and gone home.
He had spent a decade calling that decision complicated. It had been cowardly as well. The difference mattered more now than it had then.
‘What do you want me to do about Maeve?’ he asked.
‘Speak to her. Establish what she knows. Encourage a sensible resolution.’
‘Define sensible.’
‘Private. Quiet. No more correspondence with third parties.’
‘And if she doesn't agree?’
Kelleher glanced towards the window. ‘You're the expert.’
Darragh almost laughed. It was the kind of compliment that arrived wrapped around an instruction nobody wanted recorded.
‘I'm not frightening a woman out of doing her job.’
‘Nobody said frighten.’
‘You didn't have to.’
Kelleher leaned forward. ‘This company employs people. A public allegation has consequences.’
‘So does a collapsed stairwell.’
For the first time that morning, Kelleher lost the polished look. The expression beneath it was not rage. It was fear, which Darragh found considerably more informative.
‘Be careful,’ Kelleher said.
‘Of what?’
‘What you think you remember.’
Darragh rose. He left the copies where they were.
‘I'll speak to Ms Sloane,’ he said. ‘Because I want to hear what she's found. Not because you've hired me to tell her what she can say.’
‘We have a contract.’
‘Then send me the clause that says I have to lie.’
He walked out before Kelleher could decide whether to threaten him again.
***
Outside, Cork was grey and bright in the peculiar way it could manage when rain hovered without committing itself. Darragh stood beneath the building's awning and called Finbarr.
His brother answered on the fourth ring. ‘If you're ringing to borrow money, I haven't any.’
‘You own three vans.’
‘And every one of them needs something expensive. What is it?’
Darragh watched a cyclist argue with a delivery driver at the junction. ‘Do you remember Carrig Court?’
The line went quiet.
‘Of course I remember,’ Finbarr said.
‘There's someone looking into it.’
‘Good.’
Darragh closed his eyes briefly. ‘That's your first reaction?’
‘It's the one I should've had when you first told me about it.’
A bus passed, throwing spray across the kerb. Finbarr waited, not filling the silence for him. The two brothers had always shared the same stubbornness but not the same uses for it. Finbarr had chosen the sort of work that left visible dirt on his hands. Darragh had chosen the sort that could be washed off before dinner.
‘You told me to walk away,’ Darragh said.
‘I did.’
‘You could enjoy being right a bit less.’
‘I'd have to get used to it first.’
Darragh smiled despite himself. Then it faded.
‘There's an annex missing from the file.’
‘Missing now or missing then?’
‘Both.’
‘And you knew?’
‘Not enough.’
Finbarr gave a short, unhappy laugh. ‘That's not the question I asked.’
Darragh looked at his reflection in the glass door. He could see the cuffs he'd ironed while Oisín ate breakfast, clean white cotton against the dark of his coat. A little smear of strawberry jam marked the left one. He hadn't noticed it until now.
‘Yes,’ he said. ‘I knew it wasn't where it should've been.’
‘Then you know what you've to do.’
‘It's not that simple.’
‘It never is, when it's your turn.’
The words struck harder because Finbarr did not raise his voice.
‘I have the children,’ Darragh said.
‘You had them yesterday too. You don't get to use them as the reason a different family never got answers.’
Darragh could have argued. He could have said that everything he'd done was designed to keep his own household steady, that his work had paid the mortgage when the marriage ended and covered the extra costs of two homes. Those things were true. They were also a way of putting his children between himself and an old decision they had never made.
‘You're a pain in the arse,’ he said.
‘Family trait. Call me when you're ready to tell me something useful.’
The call ended.
He stayed under the awning until the rain finally began. He had built a career out of recognising the moment a conversation changed shape. Kelleher had tried to make Maeve Sloane the problem. Finbarr had refused to let him.
His phone lit with a reminder: EABHA — THURSDAY 16:00. He checked that the meeting remained blocked in his calendar, then opened Maeve's message. There was a space below it for an answer. He typed: I can meet you tomorrow at ten. Public place of your choosing. No conditions.
He read it twice. He deleted a joke about bringing his own solicitor. Then he sent it.
A reply arrived less than a minute later.
You can bring a solicitor. You can't bring a script.
He laughed, once, aloud. A passing woman glanced at him as though the weather had finally driven him mad.
He typed: Fair.
Darragh put the shoe on the draining board and looked at it for a long time. The laces had been tied into a knot only a child could regard as a practical solution. There was a smear of strawberry jam on the heel. It was difficult to imagine a clue less interested in helping him understand the rest of his life.
Eabha came in carrying a schoolbag heavy enough to qualify as building material. She saw the shoe and stopped.
‘That's mine.’
‘I'm relieved. I was beginning to think we had an extremely small burglar.’
‘It was a science experiment.’
‘Were you studying the effect of refrigeration on footwear?’
‘No. Oisín said you never notice anything in the fridge except cheese.’
Darragh looked at his daughter, then at the shoe. ‘And this proves?’
‘That you notice shoes.’
She took it from him, smiling with the fierce satisfaction of a person whose theory had survived the evidence. He wanted to laugh. He did, a little. Then his phone moved across the counter with a message from someone whose name he had not expected to see again.
Eabha watched his expression change. At twelve she noticed everything adults believed their faces could conceal. ‘Is that work?’
‘Yes.’
‘Bad work?’
‘Complicated work.’
She made a face. ‘That's what you say when you don't want to tell me.’
He could have produced a reassuring answer with almost no effort. Instead he put the phone down. ‘It's something I need to sort out, and I don't know yet how.’
Eabha examined him. ‘That's new.’
‘What is?’
‘You saying you don't know.’
The comment stayed with him after she'd left to find the other shoe. He had built a career out of sounding as though every situation could be managed if the right people were kept calm and the right phrases put on paper. At home the habit wore a kinder face: appointments confirmed, school forms signed, promises made early enough that nobody had to worry. He wondered how often certainty had become another way of choosing for other people.
Sinéad rang while he was putting away the breakfast plates. They discussed school pickup, a leaking tap and Oisín's increasingly elaborate theories about why football boots ought to count as formal shoes. She asked if he was all right. He said he had something on his mind. He did not say it was nothing.
‘Do you need to tell me?’ she asked.
‘Probably. But I want to get the facts straight first.’
‘Don't polish them till they shine,’ she said. ‘I know how you are.’
He smiled despite himself. ‘That's fair.’
After the call he opened the message again. He wrote down the date beside it and made a list of the names he could remember from the old case. He crossed out one assumption and replaced it with a question. His pen paused over the paper as the children argued in the hallway about whose turn it was to carry the recycling.
The house was untidy, loud and full of people who expected him to come back when he went out. He looked towards the sound, and for once let that expectation frighten him into telling the truth rather than keeping it tucked away.
Three dots appeared, vanished, then appeared again.
And Mr Keane? If you intend to tell me you're a good man, save us both the morning.
Darragh looked down at the jam on his cuff. He thought of his daughter's plait, of Oisín's cold shoe, of an envelope he'd carried years ago and the people who had lived with what was missing from it.
He wrote: I wasn't planning to.
It was the first entirely honest thing he'd said about the case in a long time.