Chapter One
The first thing Saoirse Bell learned about the solicitor’s office was that its waiting-room clock was seven minutes fast.
The second was that being seven minutes early had never made a single person less anxious.
She knew because she had checked her phone four times since sitting down, each glance a small act of rebellion against the clock above a framed watercolour of Howth. There was a bowl of peppermints on the table. Beside it lay a magazine celebrating the renovation of a country house in which the downstairs loo appeared to have its own architect.
Saoirse put the magazine back.
She had arrived carrying a folder, a handbag with a broken zip, and the unreasonable hope that the meeting would end with a number. Not a miraculous number. Nothing that required a bottle of champagne or an awkward speech about blessings in disguise. Just a number she could take home, write on the back of an envelope, and subtract things from until there was something left.
Rent. School trips. The car. The leak above the back bedroom window that her landlord had promised to examine in the spring, without specifying a year.
Five minutes before she left the house, Bea had asked whether a person could be allergic to uncertainty.
“If you can,” Saoirse had told her, “I’m in serious trouble.”
“I think Fionn is allergic to washing his hair.”
“That’s a moral objection, not a medical condition.”
“I could do a study.”
“Please don’t.”
Then Hannah had appeared in the hallway wearing Eoghan’s navy jumper again, despite the warmth, and had asked a question that had travelled with Saoirse all the way here.
“If the house sells, do we have to move?”
Saoirse had been reaching for her keys. She’d stopped.
“We don’t have to do anything today,” she’d said.
“That’s not an answer.”
“No. It isn’t. But it’s the one I’ve got.”
Hannah had looked at her for a moment. Fifteen was old enough to detect evasions and young enough to be furious that grown-ups still expected gratitude for them.
“Just don’t come home acting delighted if it means something I haven’t agreed to,” she’d said.
She had gone upstairs before Saoirse could answer. It was not an unreasonable request. That was the problem with Hannah lately. The child could deliver an indictment so accurate that the adult had nothing to do but stand in the hallway holding her car keys.
At the office, Saoirse opened her folder. The letter from Kelleher & Byrne sat on top, its carefully noncommittal language looking more expensive than the paper it was printed on.
We would appreciate your attendance to discuss the present position concerning the property and potential options for the estate.
Potential options. The phrase covered everything from a straightforward sale to the revelation that the house had been built over a medieval burial ground and now belonged to a bishop.
“Ms Bell?”
A young receptionist looked up from her desk.
“Yes?”
“Ms Kelleher is finishing a call. She won’t keep you long.”
“That’s grand.”
“Would you like tea or coffee?”
“No, thank you.”
Saoirse reconsidered. She had left half a cup cooling beside the washing machine and would shortly be expected to participate in a conversation about money without assaulting anyone.
“Actually, tea would be lovely. Milk, no sugar.”
“Of course.”
The receptionist disappeared through a narrow doorway.
Saoirse looked again at the letter. She could still hear Aunt Nuala complaining about the old house. It had been a nuisance, Nuala said. A drain on the heating bill, a gathering place for junk mail, and an insult to every person who had ever tried to put fitted sheets on a double bed. Yet she had never sold it. She had stayed until her health made the stairs difficult, and even then she had argued with the ambulance crew about leaving the hall light on.
Nuala Doyle was her mother’s aunt, though in Saoirse’s childhood everyone called her Aunt Nuala regardless of the family arithmetic. When she died in May, the house had been empty long enough for the garden to swallow the path. Saoirse had imagined the sale as one small, practical kindness from a woman who had always slipped banknotes into birthday cards and written Don’t spend it all on sensible things.
A kindness arriving after the person who offered it was gone.
She had not thought until this morning about how strange that was.
The front door opened with an apologetic jangle.
A man stepped in backwards, holding it for a woman with a parcel under one arm. He waited until she was through, then came inside, folded a damp umbrella with the care of someone dismantling a complicated machine, and looked at the reception desk.
“Morning. Darragh O’Connell. I might be slightly early.”
The receptionist glanced at the clock.
“You’re right on time, Mr O’Connell.”
“First time for everything.”
He was broad-shouldered, dark-haired, and dressed in a blue shirt with the sleeves rolled neatly above his wrists. There was a faint line between his brows and a crease at the edge of his mouth, as if he’d spent years both worrying and deciding not to make a production of it.
He moved aside for the woman with the parcel, who turned out to be delivering printer cartridges, and then took the seat opposite Saoirse.
He didn’t immediately look at his phone. He put it face down on his knee and glanced towards her folder before catching himself.
“Sorry,” he said. “I wasn’t reading.”
“You’d have a difficult job. My handwriting has defeated professionals.”
“I work with professionals. That doesn’t narrow it down.”
Saoirse almost smiled. Almost was what she had time for.
“Are you waiting for Ms Kelleher as well?” he asked.
“Yes.”
“Right.”
The word hung there between them. Something in his expression changed, not into recognition but into calculation.
“I’m here about a house,” he said.
Saoirse looked down at the letter in her lap.
“So am I.”
He glanced towards the receptionist, then back. “Terraced place on Rowan Street?”
For a moment she thought she had misheard him.
“Number eighteen?”
“That’s the one.”
Saoirse closed her folder.
“Why?”
It came out sharper than she’d intended. The man lifted his hands a fraction, palms visible, as if she had caught him in possession of stolen cutlery.
“Because I’ve an appointment about it,” he said. “Darragh O’Connell.”
“I heard.”
“And you are?”
“Saoirse Bell.”
“All right.”
He gave a thoughtful nod. “This might be one of those conversations that improves if we wait for the solicitor.”
“What makes you say that?”
“Well, I was expecting paperwork, and you look as though I might be the paperwork’s personal representative.”
She hadn’t meant to laugh. An unwilling breath escaped anyway.
“I was expecting a sale,” she said.
“I was expecting an explanation.”
“Of what?”
“A half-interest. Or something that looks very like a half-interest until you examine it.”
Saoirse stared at him.
“In my aunt’s house?”
“I suspect,” he said carefully, “that’s the part we’re here to find out.”
The receptionist returned carrying tea on a saucer so white it seemed to disapprove of the proceedings. Behind her, a door opened.
“Ms Bell? Mr O’Connell?” called a woman in a grey jacket. “I’m Deirdre Kelleher. Thank you both for coming.”
Both.
Saoirse set the tea down without tasting it.
* * *
Darragh had spent the drive over reminding himself that this was not a contest.
Nobody had accused him of anything. No one was trying to take his children from him, increase his rent, or force him to agree to an arrangement he hadn’t understood. There was a property file, and the file contained questions. His professional life involved sitting with people who had mistaken unanswered questions for personal attacks. He ought, therefore, to have been capable of sitting in a solicitor’s office like a reasonable man.
Instead he was watching a woman in a green jacket hold a pen as though she intended to stab an agreement before signing it.
He couldn’t entirely blame her.
He had come here believing that whatever share his late Aunt Kitty’s affairs had left him could, in due course, provide security. He had not imagined the other person with an interest in the place as someone who looked as if she had put the entire national education system to bed single-handedly and then come straight to an argument about property.
An exhausted person was not an unreasonable person. But he knew how quickly exhaustion could turn a perfectly ordinary uncertainty into the final straw.
Deirdre Kelleher shut the office door and offered them each a chair.
“Before we start,” she said, “I need to be precise about my role. Our office has been assisting with the estate administration and gathering the historic property documents. I can explain the records we have and the questions still outstanding. If either of you is considering an agreement about your individual rights, I’d strongly recommend separate independent advice.”
“Good,” said Saoirse.
“Very good,” said Darragh.
Saoirse turned towards him. “I wasn’t agreeing with you.”
“Neither was I. I was agreeing with the solicitor.”
Deirdre looked from one to the other. Her expression suggested this was not the strangest meeting she’d held before lunch.
She opened a thin file, then a thicker one. The difference between the two was not encouraging.
“The house on Rowan Street was bought many years ago by Nuala Doyle and Kathleen O’Connell,” she began. “I understand they were friends.”
“Kathleen was my father’s aunt,” Darragh said. “We called her Kitty.”
“Nuala was my mother’s aunt,” Saoirse said. “And she called the house a money pit.”
“Kitty called it a terrible investment,” Darragh said. “Apparently the women agreed on that.”
Deirdre’s mouth moved towards a smile. “They bought it together all the same.”
A photograph lay at the front of the older file. Two women stood on the steps of a narrow red-brick house, holding a bunch of keys between them. One had a cigarette tilted towards the sky. The other was laughing so hard her eyes had nearly vanished.
Saoirse recognised Nuala at once.
Not the old woman who had scolded the ambulance crew. A younger one, fierce and alive, her hair blowing across her cheek. Saoirse reached towards the picture, then stopped, as though touching it might disturb something.
“I’ve never seen that,” she said.
Darragh leaned forward, careful not to cross the desk. “That’s Kitty on the left. She wore that coat until it fell apart.”
“Nuala hated that coat,” Saoirse murmured. “She said it made your aunt look like a nightclub bouncer.”
“Apparently it was useful for getting a seat on the bus.”
Their eyes met across the photograph. This time Saoirse did smile, fleetingly and without defending herself against it.
Deirdre let the moment settle before sliding the picture into a clear sleeve.
“The evidence presently points to each woman having held a share in the property,” she said. “The later arrangements are less tidy. There are documents in both estates, correspondence from different periods, and entries that need to be checked against the registered title. I don’t want to give either of you a final answer until those checks are complete.”
“But you have reason to believe I’m entitled to something?” Darragh asked.
“There is a potential entitlement arising through Kathleen’s estate, yes. That isn’t the same as saying the transfer is completed or that you can make decisions about occupation or sale today.”
He nodded. An answer with limits. He preferred it to a confident fiction.
Saoirse was looking at the file, her pen poised above the page.
“And Nuala left her interest to me?”
“Her will names you, subject to the estate administration and the outstanding title questions.”
Saoirse wrote two words. Darragh could see only the pressure she put behind them.
“I was told the house might be sold,” she said. “I thought that’s what this meeting was about.”
“Sale is one possible route,” Deirdre replied. “But it isn’t a decision that can be made by one beneficiary alone on the information we currently have.”
There was a silence in which the ordinary noises of the building became loud: the radiators ticking, a cupboard shutting, somebody laughing at reception as if money and property were not capable of ruining an otherwise decent Wednesday.
“Right,” Saoirse said.
Darragh had heard that sort of right before. It meant somebody had been handed a new problem and would shortly be expected to thank the person who delivered it.
“What would you need to establish before anybody could discuss a sale properly?” he asked.
Deirdre ran through the outstanding title checks, estate documentation, and the need for clear legal advice on any proposed arrangement. She did not manufacture a deadline. She did not offer the comforting certainty of a valuation she had not obtained.
Saoirse asked whether there were known charges or urgent bills connected to the house. Darragh asked about insurance and whether the property had been checked since it became empty. Deirdre supplied what the file supported and marked what would require confirmation.
They were not, Darragh realised, asking opposing questions. They were asking the questions people asked when they had children and couldn’t afford to be careless.
“Is the house habitable?” Saoirse asked.
“We’d need a professional inspection to give you an informed answer,” said Deirdre. “It’s been vacant. The estate has arranged basic checks, but those aren’t a substitute for a survey.”
“Can we see it?” asked Darragh.
Saoirse turned so quickly he almost apologised for the chair he was sitting on.
“I’m not suggesting we move in,” he said. “I’m asking whether we can see the property before deciding anything.”
“I know what you said.”
“All right.”
“I just don’t know why you’re asking it.”
He took a breath. The answer he usually gave in difficult conversations was the elegant one, carefully neutral, designed to leave nobody uncomfortable. He had become so good at it that his son could imitate his face.
“Because I’ve two children,” he said, “and I rent a place that’s getting harder to pay for. I’ve been told there might be an interest in this house. Before I turn that into either a rescue plan or an expensive headache, I’d like to see what is actually there.”
Saoirse’s pen stopped moving.
“How old?”
“Twelve and seven.”
She held his gaze for half a second, then looked away.
“I’ve three. Fifteen and twins of ten.”
“Busy house.”
“It’s not a house,” she said. “It’s a small country with a fragile government.”
Darragh laughed. “I think I know the constitution.”
“Nobody knows the constitution. Fionn keeps amending it.”
The solicitor cleared her throat, though not before giving in to a smile.
“I can ask the property professional we’ve used to arrange a viewing,” she said. “That would be information-gathering only. Neither of you should treat access as an agreement about possession, and you can each bring an adviser if you wish.”
“Would Friday be possible?” Darragh asked.
“Friday,” Saoirse repeated, as if testing whether the day had done anything to deserve this.
“If that doesn’t suit—”
“It depends on school.”
“Of course.”
She looked at him again. “You really are going to agree with everything I say, aren’t you?”
“No.”
It surprised both of them.
“Good,” she said.
“I was going to offer Thursday as well.”
“Thursday’s worse.”
“Then my disagreement has been helpful.”
This time Deirdre laughed aloud.
* * *
By the time the meeting ended, Saoirse had filled three pages of notes and acquired nothing resembling a number.
What she had acquired was a man’s name, a photograph of Nuala in a coat she’d never seen, a list of decisions that could not yet be made, and the peculiar knowledge that a stranger had asked the same questions she would have asked if she’d been able to stop being angry long enough to breathe.
The anger wasn’t really directed at him. She knew that. It was directed at the rent, the waiting, the endless accumulation of little costs; at being told to be proud of surviving when what she wanted was to stop having to prove it.
She stood beside her car in the drizzle, looking down at the messages that had arrived while she was inside.
FIONN: bea says the washing machine is haunted
BEA: I said it sounded structurally unsound. he said haunted. please correct record
GRÁINNE: I’ve booked a place at choir next Tuesday. Don’t make a fuss.
HANNAH: did u find out
Saoirse could have answered the last message with a bright, impossible reassurance. She could almost hear herself doing it. No need to worry, love. I’ll sort everything.
She had delivered that sentence so many times that Hannah could now hear the lie beneath it even when the intention was kind.
NOT YET, she typed. MORE COMPLICATED THAN WE THOUGHT. I’LL TELL YOU WHAT I KNOW WHEN I’M HOME.
The typing dots appeared. Disappeared. Appeared again.
HANNAH: okay. can you get milk
Saoirse rested her forehead against the cool roof of the car. Milk. There it was. The domestic world refusing, politely and with excellent timing, to let her turn an unresolved legal meeting into the end of civilisation.
She answered YES.
“Are you all right?”
Darragh O’Connell stood a careful few feet away beneath his umbrella. He had not opened it over her, a kindness she appreciated irrationally. Men who hurried to rescue her from weather often seemed to think they had been invited to rescue her from everything.
“Depends which part of the morning you’re asking about.”
“The standing in the rain part.”
“I’m grand.”
“Right.”
“That means I’m not about to cry, if that’s what you’re worried about.”
“It wasn’t.”
He looked at the car. “I was going to say your driver’s window is open.”
Saoirse turned.
The window was lowered a good two inches. Rain had gathered along the door, and the appointment letter lay on the passenger seat just close enough to be in danger.
“Oh, for God’s sake.”
She unlocked the car and hurried to close it. Darragh held the umbrella between her and the opening without stepping closer than necessary. The small unshowy movement irritated her because she liked it.
“Thank you,” she said.
“Don’t mention it.”
“I am perfectly capable of closing a window.”
“I had no doubt.”
She looked at him. “You do this for a living, don’t you?”
“Close windows? It’s more of a hobby.”
“The careful answers.”
“I’m a family mediator.”
“Of course you are.”
“That sounded like a diagnosis.”
“I work in a school. I’ve heard every variation of ‘I understand how you feel’ ever invented. Most of the people saying it have been given an instruction sheet.”
“I don’t know how you feel,” he said. “I know you expected a different meeting. And I know that can’t have been easy.”
He didn’t add but. He didn’t tell her the house might still work out or that it was all for the best. He simply stood there while the rain continued its modest assault on the car park.
Saoirse felt the unwelcome softening of something she had been holding rigid for years.
“I thought there might be enough to get us ahead,” she said. “Just once. To not be catching up every month.”
He nodded. “That would be something.”
“And I don’t mean we’re desperate. We’re not. I work. We’re fine.”
“You don’t have to qualify it for me.”
“Apparently I do. I’m doing it.”
His smile was quiet. “Fair point.”
An engine started nearby. A woman emerged from the building and ran towards her car with a file raised over her head. For a moment Saoirse watched her and wished it were possible to protect a whole life with an A4 envelope.
“I’m sorry I was sharp in there,” she said.
“You had questions.”
“I had sharp questions.”
“Some of them were useful.”
“And some?”
“I wouldn’t put ‘Are you going to agree with everything I say?’ in a formal letter to a solicitor.”
Saoirse laughed, properly this time. It surprised her enough that she tried to stop. He looked pleased but had the decency not to look triumphant.
“For the record,” he said, “I don’t have plans to turn the place into a luxury rental or throw a fleet of bulldozers through it. I’m trying to figure out what keeps my children settled.”
“Same.”
“Then that’s a place to start.”
Saoirse regarded him across the rain. She had spent most of her adult life braced for somebody to confuse her politeness with permission. This man had done something rarer and far more unsettling: he had left room for her to say no.
“I won’t be making decisions in car parks,” she said.
“Good policy.”
“Or agreeing to anything because someone has two children and an agreeable face.”
He blinked. “An agreeable face?”
“Don’t enjoy it. I meant you look like you apologise to furniture.”
“Only when I walk into it.”
“I had a husband who once apologised to a kettle.”
The words came before she could catch them. Their ease startled her. She didn’t often bring Eoghan into first conversations. Other people became too solemn, too startled, or too eager to assure her she was brave.
Darragh did none of those things.
“Was the kettle hurt?” he asked.
“It never forgave him.”
She smiled and, for one dizzy second, heard Eoghan laughing beside her. The memory did not make the moment wrong. It made her miss him so suddenly she had to look towards the traffic.
Darragh shifted his umbrella back above himself. He didn’t ask questions she hadn’t offered to answer.
“I should go,” she said.
“Of course.”
“Friday might work. I’ll confirm through the office.”
“I’ll do the same.”
They stood a moment longer, each apparently uncertain about the social procedure for parting from someone with whom you might own a problem.
“Good luck with the haunted washing machine,” he said.
Saoirse looked at him sharply. “What?”
“Sorry. Saw the message when you showed me the window. I wasn’t trying to read it.”
“It isn’t haunted. It’s making a grinding noise.”
“That’s what they all say before the haunting.”
“I hope your children give you this much trouble.”
He smiled. “They do. They really do.”