A Seat at the Table
The first thing Maggie noticed about Patrick Walsh's house was the bicycle hanging out of the apple tree.
Not leaning against it. Not parked beneath it. Hanging from a branch about eight feet off the ground, its back wheel rotating slowly in the wind.
Paddy switched off the engine and followed her gaze.
“Right,” he said.
Maggie looked at him. “Is that part of the landscaping?”
“Not when I left.”
“Are you absolutely sure?”
“Fairly.”
He took out his phone. Before he could call anyone, the front door opened and a small boy came out backwards, dragging an aluminium stepladder that was almost twice his height. He had one wellington boot on, one trainer, and the expression of a man for whom events had become regrettably complicated.
“Finn,” Paddy called through the open car window.
The boy stopped. He looked at his uncle. He looked at the ladder. Then he closed his eyes, apparently calculating whether pretending to be asleep might help.
“Why,” Paddy asked, “is there a bicycle in the tree?”
“It's not mine.”
“I didn't ask whose it was.”
“That's because you already know.”
Maggie bit the inside of her cheek.
Paddy put his phone away. “Where's your sister?”
“Inside.”
“Where's Niamh?”
“Also inside.”
“Aoife?”
“She's the one who said we should stop touching it till you got back.”
“That sounds like excellent advice.”
Finn nodded, encouraged. “That's why I've got the ladder.”
“To stop touching it?”
“No. To get it down before you saw.”
Maggie made an unfortunate noise. Paddy turned to her, his mouth twitching. “You're allowed to laugh.”
“I don't think I am.”
“Oh, you're definitely allowed. Just don't let him climb anything while you're at it.”
He got out and headed towards the tree. Maggie stayed where she was for a moment, looking at the house. Red brick along the ground floor, pale render above, a kitchen extension at the back and two footballs lodged in the gutter. There were trainers on the front step, a child's cardigan draped over the passenger seat of an old bicycle, and a pot of lavender that somebody had knocked sideways and somebody else had carefully propped upright with a stone.
The place wasn't immaculate. It was unmistakably lived in. Maggie liked it immediately, which did nothing to calm her nerves.
She'd walked into courtrooms with less trouble in her stomach.
Paddy lifted the bike from the branch, tested the bent front wheel and set it on the grass. “How did it get up there?”
Finn regarded the bicycle as if it might explain itself.
“Wind?” he offered.
“Finn.”
“We were trying something.”
“What something?”
“A stunt.”
“Was the plan to ride it?”
“No. The plan was to see if the pulley worked.”
Paddy looked from the bicycle to a length of blue rope looped over a branch. “Right.”
“It did work,” Finn said. “For a while.”
“Until?”
“Until the bike got to the tree.”
“An unexpected obstacle.”
“Exactly.”
Maggie laughed then, properly, and Finn turned towards her. He had dark hair that looked as though it had been cut with whatever scissors happened to be nearest and a small graze across his chin.
“Who's she?” he asked.
“Finn,” Paddy said, “this is Maggie.”
“The Maggie?”
“There's only one here.”
Finn considered her. “You look normal.”
“That's what I try to tell people.”
“Niamh said you were probably posh.”
“Finn.”
“What? She did.”
Maggie stepped out of the car. “I'm afraid you're going to be disappointed. I have a leaking kitchen tap and I cut my own fringe during lockdown.”
Finn brightened. “Our tap leaks too.”
Paddy looked at the boy. “Not anymore, it doesn't.”
“It was yesterday.”
“Which tap?”
“The one outside.”
“That's a hose.”
“Oh.” Finn considered the information. “Then no, it doesn't.”
A woman came to the door carrying a tea towel. She had a round, intelligent face and the sort of brisk energy Maggie recognised from women who had spent a lifetime keeping households moving and had no intention of retiring from the position simply because their knees had begun to object.
“Patrick! I told you not to leave that bike up there.”
“I didn't put it there, Mam.”
“Well, somebody did.”
“Good afternoon to you too.”
The woman looked past him and saw Maggie. Her face changed at once—not into a hostess's fixed smile, but into clear, unguarded pleasure.
“Oh, look at you,” she said, coming down the step. “I'm Maura. Come in out of the cold.”
Maggie held out her hand. Maura ignored it and kissed her cheek.
“It's lovely to meet you,” Maggie said.
“And you. Eileen says you're a solicitor.”
Maggie blinked. “Eileen?”
“Your mother. She's just after ringing me.”
Paddy made a sound that could have been a laugh or a prayer.
“How did she even get your number?” Maggie asked.
“She's had it for years, love. Your father's been borrowing things off Des since the nineties.”
“Of course he has.”
“Anyway, she says to make sure Patrick feeds you properly, and that you're not to go fixing the bathroom tap in her house because Gerard will only break it again.”
Maggie stared at Paddy. “She rang your mother.”
“She likes my mother.”
“She's never met your mother.”
“They met in the chemist in March,” Maura said. “We had a grand chat about blood-pressure tablets and the price of grapes.”
Maggie looked up at the pale Cork sky. Her mother had built an entire diplomatic relationship while Maggie had been carefully avoiding introducing a man she'd been seeing for six weeks.
Inside the front hall, someone shouted, “FINN! IF YOU'VE TAKEN MY CHARGER, I'LL ACTUALLY KILL YOU!”
Maura closed her eyes. “Niamh, there's a visitor.”
A distant voice answered, “Well, she can charge her phone somewhere else!”
Paddy rubbed a hand over his mouth. “Welcome to the family.”
The kitchen was enormous only because everything in it was competing for space. School letters occupied one end of the table. A drying rack draped with football kits stood against the radiator. A bowl of fruit contained three bananas, a peach that had seen better days, and what appeared to be a television remote.
There were photographs everywhere: school portraits, seaside holidays, a girl in a communion dress, two little children on either side of a dark-haired woman who had Paddy's smile. On the fridge, a magnetic calendar carried six different colours of handwriting. Underneath it, somebody had written in red marker: BUY MILK OR ADMIT YOU HATE US.
Maggie felt the old tug in her chest. She knew exactly how a house full of people wrote its history without noticing.
Des Walsh sat at the kitchen table in a checked shirt with his walking stick hooked over the chair. He was reading a racing page and eating a biscuit with the solemnity of a man performing a public service.
He looked up as they came in. “Is that the solicitor?”
“Des,” Maura said.
“What? I was told we were getting a solicitor.”
“You're getting tea,” Paddy told him. “And this is Maggie.”
Des rose carefully. Paddy moved an instinctive hand towards his father and stopped when Des gave him a look.
“I can stand up, boy.”
“I can see that.”
“Good. Because your mother keeps telling people I can't.”
“Only when you try standing on chairs to change light bulbs,” Maura called.
“That was one time.”
“You fell into the laundry basket.”
“Didn't fall. Stepped.”
Maggie shook Des's hand and found herself smiling. “My father says you used to play cards together.”
“Your father owes me thirty euros.”
“He says you owe him forty.”
Des looked pleased. “Ah. He's still lying, so.”
Footsteps thundered overhead. A teenage girl appeared in the doorway, tall, dark-haired, wearing pyjama shorts and an oversized sweatshirt, a phone in one hand and a charger in the other.
“Finn, this is not yours. It's got my initials—”
She saw Maggie and stopped.
Paddy stood beside the counter. “Niamh, this is Maggie. Maggie, Niamh.”
Niamh looked her over. Maggie had the distinct impression that, had she been an essay, she would have received a mark and some concise feedback.
“Hi,” the girl said.
“Hi.”
“You're Dad's Maggie.”
“Apparently.”
“Are you actually a solicitor?”
“Yes.”
Niamh nodded. “Good. We might need one.”
Paddy looked at the ceiling. “What have you done?”
“Nothing. Yet.”
She took a glass of water and went back upstairs. Maggie watched her go.
“She's lovely,” she said.
Paddy nodded. “You see the resemblance?”
“To you?”
“To a barrister cross-examining a hostile witness.”
“That is my professional assessment, yes.”
Aoife arrived next, carrying a basket of washing and wearing the expression of someone who had been running a small country against her will. She was seventeen, with her father's eyes and a faded scar above one eyebrow. She looked from Maggie to Paddy, set the basket on a chair and sighed.
“You came.”
“I did,” Maggie said.
“Good. He was being weird all morning.”
“I wasn't,” Paddy said.
“He cleaned the oven.”
“I clean the oven.”
“You've cleaned it twice since Christmas. Once because Granny said it smelled like a tyre fire, and once today.”
Maura made a small victorious noise at the sink.
Aoife offered Maggie a hand. “Nice to meet you.”
“You too.”
“Has Finn explained the bicycle?”
“In considerable detail.”
“None of it's true,” Aoife said, and went to put the wash on.
Paddy waited until she'd left. “See? Lovely children. All four of them. Makes you wonder why I drink tea by the gallon.”
Maggie looked towards the hall and lowered her voice. “Are they all right with me being here?”
“Yeah.”
“Paddy.”
He caught the seriousness in her face and put down his mug. “Aoife asked when she could meet you. Niamh said she wouldn't mind, provided I didn't make her be nice about it. Finn was excited because he's under the impression you can get him out of homework. And Lena said she'd see how it went.”
“Lena?”
“My niece.” His voice gentled on the word. “Twelve. Not a big fan of surprises.”
“I could have come another day.”
“I told them you might be here. Nobody's been ambushed.” He paused. “If it's too much, I'll bring you home. No big production.”
Maggie heard Aoife ask her brother, somewhere upstairs, whether he had been born without an ounce of sense. The question was followed by the unmistakable sound of someone laughing in spite of themselves.
“No,” she said. “I want to stay.”
Paddy touched the back of her hand where it rested on the counter. A fleeting touch. Enough.
Lena came downstairs when the potatoes were nearly ready. Maggie was at the table helping Finn repair the torn cover of a library book with clear tape; he had explained that the book had fallen under a lawn mower, which Maggie was choosing, for her own peace of mind, not to investigate.
Lena stopped at the doorway. She had a narrow face, brown hair tied back carelessly, and a silver chain around her neck with a tiny enamel star on it. Her eyes went first to the book, then to Maggie's hands, then to Paddy at the cooker.
“This is Lena,” Paddy said. “Lena, Maggie.”
“Hello,” Maggie said.
“Hi.”
There was a chair empty beside Finn. Maggie didn't pat it or indicate that Lena ought to sit. She placed a strip of tape over the book's split spine and held it up for inspection.
“You might get away with that,” she told Finn.
“Depends on the librarian.”
“She's a hard woman?”
“She used to teach Granny.”
“That explains it.”
Lena's mouth moved, almost a smile. Then she pulled out the empty chair.
“That's not how she taught him to fix books,” she said.
Maggie slid the tape towards her. “Show me.”
Lena took the book without ceremony, examined the repair, and carefully trimmed the excess. She pressed the spine flat with the side of her thumbnail.
“You have to leave it under something heavy for an hour.”
Finn looked stricken. “But I need to finish it tonight.”
“You should've thought of that before the lawn mower.”
Maggie watched the siblings look at one another. Something passed between them that she wasn't invited to translate.
“All right,” Finn said. “I'll use another book.”
“Look at you,” Maggie said. “A literary household.”
“It's a maths textbook,” Lena replied.
“Even better. It's finally doing some good.”
A sudden laugh escaped Lena. She covered it quickly by looking down at the tape, but Paddy had heard. Maggie could tell by the way he turned at the cooker and then, equally quickly, went back to the potatoes.
She didn't look at him. She knew that kind of restraint. Parents learned it: the art of not making a child sorry for showing you something tender.
Dinner was a negotiation that appeared to have been ongoing for years. Finn disliked carrots when they were cooked but ate them raw from the chopping board. Niamh claimed the chicken was dry, then asked for seconds. Des wanted the gravy brought over before he'd tell anybody what he thought of it. Maura threatened to retire from cooking and was met with four immediate objections and an offer from Paddy to do Thursdays.
Maggie was seated between Paddy and Lena, opposite Aoife. She reached for the water jug at the same time as Paddy and their fingers bumped. He moved his hand away, smiling at her, and Finn saw it.
“Are you two going to get married?” he asked.
Niamh shut her eyes. “Finn.”
“What? It's a question.”
“It's a weird question.”
“It has an answer.”
“Not one you need before dessert,” Paddy said.
Finn thought about that. “So, after dessert?”
Aoife snorted into her drink. Des began laughing so hard Maura told him to swallow his potato before he choked.
Maggie folded her napkin. “I think your uncle and I are going to finish our dinner first.”
“Fair,” Finn said. “I don't want to get married either. I just want the cake.”
“First sensible thing you've said all day,” Des told him.
Niamh eyed Maggie over her glass. “Do you have kids?”
“Three. Molly's fifteen, and I've two boys.”
“How old?”
“Eleven and eight.”
Finn brightened. “Does the eight-year-old play football?”
“He's better at talking about it than playing.”
“Same as Finn, then,” Lena said.
“I'm very good,” Finn protested.
“At getting it stuck in trees.”
It was easy, after that, to talk about school and disastrous sports days and the extraordinary sums of money required to keep children in shoes. Maggie told the story of her youngest son going to school in two different trainers because he'd insisted they gave him better balance. Aoife admitted she'd once walked into an exam wearing her younger sister's blazer and hadn't noticed until the teacher asked why her sleeves were halfway up her forearms.
Paddy was quiet for a while, listening. Maggie saw Aoife glance at him twice, perhaps surprised to find her father content to let somebody else steer the table. When Maura asked about Maggie's work, Maggie told her about the practice, about clients who rang during Christmas dinner and the partner who still printed emails so he could read them with a pen in his hand.
“Why doesn't he just reply on the computer?” Finn asked.
“Because he's a man who enjoys turning one job into three.”
Des pointed his fork at her. “Nothing wrong with paper.”
“Spoken like a man who owes my father thirty euro,” Maggie said.
“Forty,” Des replied, “if you believe him.”
Maura laughed. Beneath the table, Paddy's knee came lightly against Maggie's, stayed for a moment, then moved away.
She had expected to feel examined. Instead she felt, increasingly, like someone had pulled out a chair for her and carried on passing the salt.
After dinner, Aoife and Niamh cleared the plates. Paddy checked the back door and brought in a football, a soaking towel and the damaged bicycle wheel, apparently because he'd decided no one could be trusted to leave any of them alone. Finn asked if Maggie wanted to see the pulley. She said she'd rather live to see her next birthday. He took that as a promising maybe.
Maura showed Maggie where the tea bags were kept. “He'll offer to make it himself,” she said, nodding towards her son, “but he'll forget the milk while he's telling you some story about a job.”
“I heard that,” Paddy said.
“You were meant to.”
Maggie filled the kettle. Through the kitchen window she could see Lena at the washing line, taking pegs out of an old tin and dropping them into her pocket. Her little brother followed her in an exaggerated crouch, trying to approach unseen. She turned without looking and flicked a peg at his shoes. Finn collapsed into the grass, mortally wounded.
“Those two have a good bond,” Maggie said.
Maura's hands paused on the drawer she'd opened. “They had to get close quickly.”
Maggie kept her eyes on the garden. “Paddy told me about his sister.”
“Siobhán.”
“Yes.”
Maura nodded. “She'd have liked you.”
Maggie turned. “You don't have to say that.”
“No, I don't.” Maura closed the drawer. “She had a great eye for people. Terrible eye for men, mind you. She'd have laughed herself sick if she'd heard me telling you that.”
Maggie waited. She knew the difference between silence that wanted to be filled and silence that was making room.
“Everyone was in here the week after the funeral,” Maura said. “People bringing food, somebody always offering to take the children. I remember standing over the sink wondering why the plates kept coming, as if washing them was all I was good for. Then Patrick said the children would stay here with him. Not for a week. Not until somebody worked out a plan. He just said it, and got up the next morning and put four lunchboxes on the table.”
Her voice hadn't broken. That made the pain in it more difficult to hear.
“And he's never acted like he's owed a medal for it,” she added. “Neither should anybody else. He loves them. That's the beginning and the end of it.”
“I know.”
Maura looked at her. “I'd say you do.”
The kettle clicked off. Maggie poured the water and gave Maura a moment to choose whether the conversation was over.
It was.
“Now,” Maura said briskly, “does your father still insist on buying those dreadful supermarket sausages?”
“Every week.”
“Tell him Des has a butcher who'll sort him out.”
“I'll tell him. He won't listen.”
“No,” Maura said. “They never bloody do.”
Paddy found Maggie in the garden a little after six. She was standing by the apple tree, looking at the frayed blue rope still tied to its branch. The bicycle had been moved into the shed, though she could hear Finn explaining to Lena that version two of the pulley would solve everything.
“You survived,” Paddy said.
“Barely. Your dad asked me to represent him in a card game dispute dating back to 1994.”
“Don't do it. You'll never get paid.”
She leaned into him when he came to stand beside her. “They're lovely.”
“They're nosy and loud and permanently hungry.”
“So are mine.”
Paddy slipped an arm around her. For a while they watched a gull settle on the back wall and instantly get chased away by a smaller, furious bird.
“You all right?” he asked.
“Yeah.”
“Sure?”
She turned into his side. “I didn't realise how nervous I was till I got here.”
“Could've fooled me.”
“I'm a solicitor. Looking calm while privately considering whether to throw up is half the job.”
He laughed and brushed his thumb over the sleeve of her coat.
“You didn't have to impress them, Maggie.”
“I know.”
“Do you?”
She considered lying. He had a way of asking a straightforward question and waiting for her actual answer, which was profoundly inconvenient in a man with such good arms.
“I wanted them to like me,” she said.
“They do.”
“You don't know that.”
“Finn gave you his best seat. Niamh showed you the video of her school play, which she won't show me. Aoife asked whether you'd like to come to her birthday. Lena let you fix her book.”
“Finn's book.”
“It's been Lena's library card since Christmas. Trust me, love, it was a big gesture.”
Maggie looked towards the kitchen window. Maura was at the sink, laughing with Aoife. Des had taken his chair to the table and was apparently instructing Niamh on how to shuffle cards.
“And you?” she asked.
Paddy turned. “What about me?”
“Did I impress you?”
He bent his head until his forehead touched hers. “You've already done that.”
There it was again, that unbearable plainness. He'd told her he liked her. He'd told his children she mattered. He'd asked her into the house. None of it had required an elaborate speech, and all of it was making the little defences she'd spent years building feel faintly ridiculous.
She kissed him first.
From the upstairs window a voice shouted, “WE CAN SEE YOU!”
Maggie broke away, laughing.
Paddy didn't even look up. “NIAMH, I CAN SEE YOUR BEDROOM FLOOR FROM HERE. PICK UP YOUR CLOTHES.”
The window slammed.
“Very romantic,” Maggie said.
“I do my best.”
His phone vibrated. Maggie felt him stiffen before he'd looked at the screen. He took it out, read the name and let out a breath.
“It's Rachel,” he said. “The girls' mam.”
“Answer it.”
He did. “How are you?”
Maggie stepped away to give him space, but he caught her hand before she could go, his thumb resting loosely across her knuckles. She stayed beside him, listening to the indistinct rise and fall of a woman's voice through the phone.
“Yeah,” Paddy said. “Aoife mentioned it. No, don't drive over tonight; I'll bring the bag tomorrow. Of course she's allowed to bring the dress.” He smiled. “Rachel, she's seventeen. I'm not getting between her and a dress.”
A pause. Then: “Yeah, Maggie's here.”
Maggie went still. He met her eyes, not asking her to be anyone other than herself.
“She is,” he said into the phone. “I'll tell her. Talk tomorrow.”
He ended the call.
“What?” Maggie asked.
“Rachel says hello.”
“Oh.”
“And that Aoife shouldn't be allowed to tell you the story about the hotel in Galway. There's apparently some detail that makes Rachel look worse than she deserves.”
Maggie laughed. “Now I need to hear it.”
“Thought you might.”
She looked at the phone in his hand. “Was that all right?”
“What?”
“Her knowing I was here.”
Paddy's eyes narrowed, not in annoyance but in thought. “Maggie, Rachel and I have been apart six years. We work at getting the girls' lives right between our houses. That doesn't mean we're pretending nothing else happens.”
“I wasn't asking for a promise.”
“I know. I'm telling you the truth.”
It landed more gently than reassurance would have.
“Right,” she said.
“Right.”
He pocketed the phone. “Now. I'd better get you home before your mother sends out a search party.”
Maggie pulled her own phone from her bag. Twenty-seven messages, four photographs, and a voice note from Kitty that she refused to play on principle.
“She'd have to fight your mother for custody,” she said.
“True. Mam's already asked if you're coming next Sunday.”
“Has she?”
“Mm.”
“What did you say?”
“That I'd ask you.”
Maggie looked at the warm rectangles of the kitchen windows, at the bicycle wheel visible through the shed door, and at the man beside her who had brought her here without asking her to pretend any of this was easy.
“Ask me, then,” she said.
Paddy smiled. “Would you like to come for dinner next Sunday?”
“I would.”
“Good.”
He kissed her once, quick and sure, and took her hand as they walked towards the house to say goodbye.
Before they reached the back step, the kitchen door flew open. Finn appeared with the repaired library book tucked under one arm and a coil of rope in the other.
“Paddy! Maggie! If I use two pulleys, do you reckon we could lift a person?”
“No,” Paddy said.
“Depends how heavy,” Maggie said at exactly the same time.
Paddy turned to her.
She took one look at his face and started laughing.
From inside the house, Lena called, “DON'T ENCOURAGE HIM!”
Maggie caught Paddy's hand again and held on while he laughed with her. The garden was cold, her phone wouldn't stop vibrating, and someone inside was arguing about where the biscuits had gone.
She was due in court at nine the following morning. There were three loads of washing waiting at home, an email she'd promised to send, and Molly would undoubtedly want a complete report before bedtime.
For the first time in a long time, Maggie didn't resent a single one of the people waiting for her. She wanted to tell Molly everything; she wanted to hear her laugh. She wanted her boys to meet Finn. She wanted to see whether Maura would like Eileen as much after the two of them had spent an entire Sunday at the same table.
Most of all, she wanted another afternoon in this impossible, crowded house.
“Next Sunday,” she said to Paddy.
“Next Sunday,” he answered.
And when Finn asked again about the pulleys, Maggie said, “Start with a bag of potatoes. If that survives, we'll talk.”
Paddy shook his head. “I'm going to regret bringing you here.”
“Almost certainly,” she said, and followed him inside.