By the following Thursday, Aoife had almost convinced herself she had imagined the whole thing.
Not him. Him she remembered with insulting clarity—the coat, the grin that arrived like he didn’t entirely trust it, the rough, tired beauty of him leaning under the pub sign in the rain. But people said things at midnight they didn’t mean in daylight. Men especially. Men in pubs should, as a category, come with warning labels and a small civic handbook.
So when she came off shift with vinegar on her hands and tiredness sitting behind her eyes, she was prepared for disappointment. Prepared to step out onto the pavement and find nothing there but damp air and buses and the familiar humiliation of having believed a man at exactly the wrong hour.
Instead, Cian was across the road at the chipper, arguing with the lad behind the counter as if national peace might depend on the proper distribution of salt.
Aoife stopped under the pub awning and watched him through the steamed-up glass.
He had changed into a charcoal jumper that made his shoulders look unfair and had apparently attempted to tame his hair for the occasion, which only made him look more himself once the rain had got at it. One hand was braced on the counter. The other held coins. He was smiling in a way that suggested he knew he was being difficult and intended to remain that way until justice prevailed.
The chipper boy threw up both hands. Cian said something that made the woman waiting behind him snort into her scarf.
Sinead came out behind Aoife, lighting a cigarette with all the solemnity of a priest at a funeral. “Mother of God,” she said. “He’s back.”
Aoife kept her face blank. “People do return to restaurants, yes.”
“He’s buying chips in advance. That is either romance or severe carbohydrate dependency.”
“Both are possible.”
Sinead leaned sideways for a better look. “That man looks like trouble with forearms.”
Aoife buttoned her coat. “You say that like it’s rare.”
“It’s rare at that quality.”
Aoife tried not to smile and failed in one corner of her mouth. “Go home, Sinead.”
“You wound me. I’m invested now. If you marry him, I want it noted I backed the enterprise early.”
“If I marry a man I met over the Guinness taps, I expect you to stage an intervention.”
“Absolutely not. I’ll wear something fabulous and tell people I always knew.”
Aoife stepped off the curb before her friend could say anything worse. The road shone black with drizzle. Cian looked up as she reached the chipper door, and the expression that crossed his face was so plainly relieved it took the breath out of the moment before she could guard herself against it.
“You came,” he said.
Aoife glanced around theatrically. “To the place where I work and then directly beside it? A wild act of travel, I know.”
He huffed a laugh. “No, I mean—you came.”
“You’re the one who set the appointment.”
“Still.”
The chipper boy slapped a paper parcel onto the counter. “Here. Before Romeo starts another union dispute.”
“I was asking for structural integrity,” Cian said, taking the parcel. “There’s no point in chips if the bag gives way before the vinegar settles.”
“There’s no point in me serving you if you’re going to lecture me like a disappointed uncle.”
Aoife accepted the parcel when Cian held it out for her inspection. Hot through the paper. Heavy. Properly greasy. “He’s right,” she told the boy. “Your bag work has grown lax.”
The boy stared at her. “Get out.”
“See?” Cian said, opening the door for her. “You understand me.”
“That’s not necessarily a point in your favour.”
They stepped back into the wet night. The city smelled of rain on stone, fryer oil, traffic, and cigarettes. A taxi hissed past. Somewhere behind them a girl in heels was laughing with the exhausted aggression of the freshly dumped.
Cian tipped his head toward the canal. “Walk?”
“With chips?”
“That was the core of the proposal.”
Aoife looked at him for a beat—at the hopeful stubbornness in his face, the way he seemed to be trying not to crowd the moment by wanting anything from it too quickly.
“Fine,” she said. “But if you’ve brought me to a scenic location for murder, I’ll be difficult about it.”
“I’m starting to think you’d be difficult from principle.”
“I was raised with standards.”
They headed down the street shoulder to shoulder, sharing chips from the bag as they walked. The paper warmed their fingers through the cold. Vinegar hit the back of Aoife’s throat in the best possible way. Cian insisted on handing her the good chips—the thick, properly golden ones, not the skinny pale tragedies that sometimes sneaked in as filler. When she called him on it, he looked almost offended.
“I’m not taking your best chip in front of you,” he said. “What sort of man do you think I am?”
“A manipulative one.”
“A gentleman, actually.”
“From Cabra?”
He pressed a hand to his chest. “Cruel.”
“You recover quickly.”
“Only because I sense secret affection.”
“You sense delusion.”
He smiled into the damp air like he didn’t mind.
They crossed toward the canal where the city loosened a little, all reflected lights and black water and Georgian windows watching from behind rain. Thursday night had not gone to bed yet but was thinking about it. Buses dragged themselves by half-empty. A cyclist tore past with no lights and a death wish. Two students shared an umbrella too small for either of them and kissed badly at a crossing.
Cian tore the top of the bag to make more room. “Tell me something true about you.”
Aoife glanced sideways. “That sounds like a priest with unusual hobbies.”
“I’m serious.”
“So am I. Dangerous wording.”
“Fine.” He thought for a second. “Tell me something unflattering about yourself.”
“That’s most of my best material.”
“Go on.”
Aoife stole another chip. “I hold grudges long past the point where God or science would recommend.”
“How long?”
“I still hate a girl called Fiona from primary school for claiming she’d been cast as an orphan in Oliver! when in fact she was tree number three.”
He turned to her, delighted. “That’s not a grudge. That’s moral clarity.”
“Thank you. Finally, a man of intelligence.”
“And you?”
“And what?”
“What’s true and unflattering?”
She looked out over the canal. The black water held the city in pieces. “I can smell when the rent is due,” she said. “Everything in me goes tight. Even if I’ve got enough. Even if I’m grand. I start calculating like the walls are about to come in.”
He was quiet for a second. When she looked at him, his expression had changed. Less playful. More open.
“Same,” he said.
The word landed between them with more intimacy than flirtation had.
Aoife tucked her free hand into her pocket. “Your turn.”
He nodded once. “I’m bad at not making everything about the thing I want.”
“The acting.”
He looked faintly embarrassed. “Yeah.”
“That’s not unflattering. That’s just ambition.”
“It is when there’s rent and work and your ma standing at the sink pretending she doesn’t mind if you miss dinner again because you’re at some idiotic open call in Bray or town or London or wherever they’ve decided to dangle the carrot.”
His voice had roughened. Not much. Just enough to show the skin under it.
“So don’t go,” Aoife said gently.
He laughed without humour. “That’s the problem. I’d rather choke than not go.”
There it was again—that hard bright wire of him. Not vanity. Need.
Aoife understood need. Not his, maybe, but the shape of it. The way it sat in the body like an extra bone.
They walked in silence for a few steps, the easy kind that didn’t beg to be filled.
Then Cian said, “I nearly didn’t come tonight.”
She looked over. “Why?”
“Because if you’d forgotten, I’d have looked like a full eejit.”
“You do have a face that could survive public humiliation.”
“That’s exactly what my mother says before Christmas.”
Aoife laughed. “And yet you came anyway.”
He shrugged one shoulder. “You seemed worth being embarrassed for.”
There were men who said things because they liked how the line sounded. Cian said them as if they’d escaped him and now he had to stand there owning the damage.
Aoife felt it low in her stomach and hated him a bit for it.
“Careful,” she said. “I’m not as charming sober.”
“I’m not, either.”
“That’s not true.”
“No?” He looked at her. “I think sober I’m worse. Less shiny.”
“Good thing I don’t trust shiny.”
“Yeah,” he said softly. “I’d guessed that.”
At the stone wall by the canal, they stopped. Cian shook a few last chips from the bottom of the bag. Salt clung to his fingers. Aoife took one and their hands brushed—a brief contact, warm despite the cold, and too deliberate to be accidental by the time either of them drew back.
The city seemed to notice. Or maybe she only did.
A group of lads passed behind them singing something tuneless and obscene about heartbreak and county colours. One of them glanced at Aoife, then at Cian, and wisely kept moving.
“You live with friends?” she asked, because she wanted the moment to settle rather than split open completely.
“Flat in Phibsborough,” he said. “Two lads, mould, one frying pan between us. Luxury arrangement.”
“How bad’s the bathroom?”
He considered. “Emotionally devastating.”
“Ah. So nearly en suite.”
“Essentially a spa if you hate yourself.”
She laughed again, and this time he looked pleased enough with himself to be dangerous.
“And you?” he asked.
“Still at home.”
“With your family?”
“With my mam. My brother’s out in Blanch now because he’s decided adulthood is paying too much for less floor space.”
“Does he hate me already?”
Aoife turned toward him, surprised into a grin. “You’ve not met him.”
“Don’t need to. He’s an older brother. He hates me on principle.”
“That is actually fair.” She nudged the chip bag toward him. “Niall thinks most men are structurally unsound.”
“Is he wrong?”
“Rarely, annoyingly.”
“And what does your ma think?”
“About men?”
“About me.”
Aoife blinked. “She doesn’t know you exist.”
“Yet.”
The confidence of him. Jesus.
“You’re very fast for a man who spent last week pretending not to be terrified.”
“I was terrified,” he said easily. “I’m just learning to operate through it.”
That answer sat in her chest a second longer than it should have. Something in it felt like a key in a lock she hadn’t admitted existed.
They started walking again, slower now, their route becoming less destination than excuse. Cian pointed out a theatre poster with an actor he knew from a workshop and said the man was sound but took himself fatally seriously. Aoife told him about a woman from the pub who treated every pub quiz as a military campaign and once hid answer sheets in her bra. He told her about turning up to an advert casting and being told to “look more aspirational,” as though he might fetch a different face out of his pocket. She told him about dropping out of college and pretending it was temporary until temporary became a shape she wore too well.
“You should go back,” he said.
She made a face. “You sound like Niall.”
“I’m sure he’s handsome in a severe way.”
“He’s not handsome at all when he’s right.”
“You should still go back.”
Aoife kicked lightly at a loose stone on the pavement. “With what money?”
“With the money you’ll make after writing something devastating and making everyone who ignored you look stupid.”
She glanced at him. “You say that very confidently for a man who’s heard exactly three opinions of mine and two were about chips.”
“I’ve heard the way you talk,” he said. “You don’t say things like someone who means to leave them in her own head forever.”
The stupid, awful thing was that she nearly stopped walking.
No one had said it to her that plainly. Not without a lecture attached. Not without turning it into a moral failure or a family plan or a speech about practicality. He said it as if it were already true and the only remaining question was when the rest of the world would catch up.
“To be clear,” she said after a second, “I reserve the right to find you insufferable for that.”
He smiled. “I’d be disappointed if you didn’t.”
Rain began again, soft at first. Then steadier. Dublin never committed halfway to anything inconvenient. Cian looked up, then toward a row of shops gone dark for the night.
“Come on,” he said.
He caught her hand then—not a snatch, not ownership, just the clean instinct to move her out of the weather faster. His palm was warm and calloused, his grip sure without being hard. Aoife’s breath hitched once in sheer surprise before she could turn it into annoyance.
He led her beneath the narrow shelter of a shuttered newsagent. The rain came down harder, silvering the street beyond the awning. For a second they were both laughing, slightly breathless from the short run, standing too close because the dry patch allowed for nothing else.
Cian still had her hand.
Neither of them mentioned it.
Water drummed on metal above them. A bus rolled past throwing yellow light over his face, then took it with it again. Close like this, she could see the faint shadow of stubble across his jaw, the tiny pale mark near his temple, the concentration with which he was not looking at her mouth.
Aoife should have pulled away. Sensible girls pulled away before the air got this charged, before a hand became an argument, before a city night convinced you that one ordinary man might alter the architecture of your life.
Instead she said, “You run like a man who was bad at school sports.”
He stared at her for one stunned beat and then laughed into the dark. “That’s vicious.”
“You nearly lost a shoe.”
“It was slippery.”
“You moved like a startled horse.”
“I’m never recovering from that.”
“Good.”
He was still laughing when he let go of her hand. The absence of it registered immediately, like a door closing somewhere inside her.
“Tell me something true now,” he said.
“I already did.”
“No, a different one. One you don’t say much.”
Aoife leaned back against the shutter and folded her arms, buying herself a second. Rain smell. Wet stone. Him.
“Fine,” she said. “I don’t like needing anyone.”
He didn’t answer straightaway.
“Because people disappoint you?” he asked.
“Because they can.”
“That’s not the same thing.”
“It is if you’ve lived on enough promises.”
His face changed—some small private understanding passing through it. “Who promised you things?”
She smiled without humour. “That sounds far too much like therapy.”
“Maybe I’d be excellent at therapy.”
“You’d flirt with the patients.”
“Only the difficult ones.”
“I’m serious.”
“So am I.”
She looked out at the rain. “My dad,” she said at last. “Among others.”
The words sat between them quietly. Not dramatic. Worse than dramatic. Ordinary.
“He around?” Cian asked.
“Sometimes in photographs.”
He took that in. Didn’t fill the silence with pity, which would have ruined everything. “Mine’s around,” he said. “Which isn’t always the better arrangement.”
Aoife turned back to him.
“He’s not—” Cian rubbed a hand over his jaw. “He’s not evil. Just one of those men who can make a room feel like you owe him admiration for coming into it. Good stories, bad temper, vanishes when real work starts. My ma did the lot. Still does.”
There was no performance in the telling. Just fact, worn smooth by long use.
Aoife nodded once. “Then your ma and mine should split a bottle and compare battle medals.”
A smile tugged at his mouth. “They’d terrify the city.”
“God willing.”
The rain eased by degrees. Not stopping. Dublin rarely granted clean endings. But it softened enough that the street beyond the awning came back into use—cars, footsteps, someone dragging a wheelie bag over uneven pavement.
Cian looked at her in the half-light. “Can I kiss you?”
There it was. No lunge. No assumption. No pub-boy opportunism. Just the question, open and low and somehow more intimate than the answer could be.
Aoife felt the whole night gather into that one point.
“You ask that like you’re prepared for me to say no,” she said.
“I am.”
“And if I do?”
“Then I walk you to your bus and think about it for an unhealthy length of time.”
She laughed softly despite the way her pulse had gone fierce. “Honest.”
“Usually a design flaw.”
She let him wait one second longer than either of them enjoyed. Then she said, “All right.”
He moved like a man determined not to ruin it. One hand touched lightly at her jaw, giving her every chance to change her mind, and when she didn’t, his mouth found hers with a care that undid her more quickly than hunger might have done.
He kissed like he paid attention. Like he’d been listening all evening and had no intention of becoming stupid now. Warm, unshowy, and devastating in its restraint at first—then deeper when she rose into it, when her hand caught in the front of his jumper, when the whole city seemed to narrow to rain and breath and the stunned fact of him.
Aoife had been kissed before. More than once. Enough to know the difference between a man kissing to take and a man kissing to discover.
Cian kissed to discover.
When he drew back, it was only far enough to look at her properly, eyes dark and a little wrecked.
“Well,” he said, voice rough.
“Don’t get smug.”
“I’m fighting for my life not to.”
She smiled before she could stop herself. “You’re very annoying.”
“I know.”
They stood there another minute, maybe two, the air changed beyond repair.
Then Aoife said, because she had to put some kind of structure back around herself, “You’ve lipstick on you.”
“Where?”
“Everywhere, tragically.”
He scrubbed a hand over his mouth, and she laughed again. He watched her laugh as if it were payment.
By the time they reached her bus stop, the rain had gone back to mist. The shelter light buzzed with bureaucratic despair. A man in a fluorescent jacket slept sitting up at the far end of the bench. The timetable was optimistic fiction.
Cian stood beside her with his hands in his pockets. Close enough to matter. Not close enough to presume.
“You’ve an audition tomorrow,” Aoife said.
He glanced over. “How d’you know that?”
“You have the face of a man carrying one around like internal bleeding.”
That made him grin. “Tomorrow afternoon. Small part in a telly thing.”
“Will you get it?”
“I’ve no idea.”
“Do you want it?”
He tipped his head, considering honesty. “I want all of them. That’s the embarrassing bit.”
“No,” Aoife said quietly. “That’s the human bit.”
His eyes held hers.
The bus did not come. Of course it didn’t. Dublin liked love stories best when transport was failing. They talked instead. About films. About the worst jobs they’d had. His had involved unloading bathroom tiles in Swords at six in the morning while hungover enough to see God. Hers had involved telephone fundraising for a charity she actually believed in, made unbearable by a supervisor named Alan who referred to women as “girls” well into his forties. He told her he read plays the way some men read race cards—scribbling notes, circling possibilities, trying to see how a life might open if someone would only cast him in it. She told him she still wrote lines in the margins of newspapers and receipts because if she didn’t, they rattled around in her head all day like loose screws.
“Can I see something you’ve written?” he asked.
“No.”
“Harsh.”
“It’s private.”
“So’m I.”
Aoife gave him a look. “You are absolutely not private.”
His mouth twitched. “That’s hurtful.”
“It’s accurate.”
He leaned back against the bus shelter glass. “One day you’ll let me read something.”
“One day you’ll earn it.”
The answer pleased him far too much. “That sounds promising.”
“It sounds conditional.”
“Same difference.”
At last the bus lumbered into view, late enough to offend. Aoife felt the odd, childish flare of annoyance that the night had to end because clocks were small tyrants and she had work again and this was still only Thursday and not some suspended world built for them alone.
The doors hissed open.
She turned toward him, suddenly shy in a way she despised. “Right.”
“Right,” he echoed, equally unwilling to make a bad job of goodbye.
She stepped onto the bus, then stopped at the first stair and looked back. He was still down on the pavement, head tilted up, one hand lifted slightly as if he had started to reach for her and thought better of it.
“When’s the audition?” she asked.
“Two.”
“After—if you’re not pretending to be dead from rejection or fame—you can come by the pub.”
His expression went still in that same way it had the first night, as though hope made him careful.
“You want me to?”
Aoife rolled her eyes because otherwise she might have had to admit too much. “Don’t make me repeat myself in public, Cian.”
A slow smile opened across his face. “After two,” he said.
The bus driver cleared his throat with theatrical bitterness.
Aoife moved inside and took the nearest seat. Through the smeared window she watched Cian step back from the curb, hands in his coat pockets again, mouth still marked faintly by her lipstick despite his efforts. He looked younger when he smiled and older when he stood still. Like someone the city had already tried and failed to harden properly.
As the bus pulled away, he lifted two fingers in a lazy salute.
Aoife looked forward before she could do something humiliating like grin at the glass all the way home. But the shape of him stayed with her anyway, bright as a bruise.
At home, her mam was asleep with the telly on low and a cardigan folded over herself like armour. Aoife let herself in quietly, kicked off her shoes at the mat, and stood for one second in the dark hall with the absurd sensation that she had come back altered in some visible way.
In her room, she emptied her pockets onto the bedside table: keys, lip balm, one hair elastic, a tenner, and a folded chip receipt she didn’t remember keeping.
Frowning, she opened it.
On the back, in hurried blue pen, was written:
In case the bus crashes, or you decide I was a hallucination.
— Cian
Below it, a number.
Aoife sat down slowly on the edge of the bed.
The handwriting was a mess. The confidence of the note irritated her on principle. The fact that he had clearly written it at some point during the evening and waited to slip it to her without spectacle did something smaller and more dangerous.
She read it again.
Then once more, because apparently she had become the sort of woman who sat in the dark smiling at chip-shop stationery.
From the doorway, her mam’s sleepy voice floated down the hall. “Aoife?”
Aoife startled and folded the receipt too fast. “Yeah?”
“You’re home late.”
“It’s Thursday.”
“That explains nothing.”
Aoife laughed under her breath. “Go back asleep, Mam.”
A pause. “You sound pleased with yourself,” her mother called.
“Delirious from vinegar.”
“Mm-hm.”
Silence settled again. The old house gave its usual night sounds—the groan in the hot-water pipes, the faint rattle of a sash window not fitted right, a car rolling slow outside.
Aoife lay back without changing, the note still in her hand.
She knew better than to build futures out of one kiss and a phone number. Knew better than to start weaving meaning through coincidence and hunger and the flattering shock of being seen. Men disappointed. Work got in the way. Rent came due. Ambition made cowards of people and then asked to be applauded for the performance.
Still.
When she closed her eyes, she could feel his hand at her jaw again, hear his voice asking as if the answer mattered, see the way he had looked at her from the pavement when the bus doors opened.
Small, she thought.
Dangerous.
Then she reached for the phone on her bedside table, keyed in the number before she could be sensible, and typed one line.
Try not to become unbearable if you get the part tomorrow.
She stared at it for exactly three heartbeats and sent it.
The reply came before she had even set the phone down.
Too late. I was unbearable by birth.
Aoife pressed the heel of her hand over her mouth, laughing soundlessly into the dark.
Then the screen lit again.
Come by the pub after two, yeah?
And because she was already in farther than wisdom approved, because the night still tasted of vinegar and rain and the first man in a long time who had asked before he kissed her, Aoife typed back:
Don’t make me repeat myself in public.
The three dots appeared almost at once, vanished, came back.
Eventually his reply arrived.
Jesus. I’m finished.
Aoife set the phone on her chest and stared up at the ceiling, smiling in spite of herself, while somewhere below her the house breathed and the city went on being wet and difficult and full of people trying to become things.
Outside, rain touched the glass.
Inside, something had begun.